The Weekly Delivered Legal Notices

The Silicon Valley Voice

Power To Your Voice

The Silicon Valley Voice

Power To Your Voice

Santa Clara Charter Change for Procurement: Measure C

Weekly Staff

Measure C aims to change Santa Clara's City Charter threshold for council approval of public works contracts, from $1,000 to $250,000.

Santa Clara’s Measure C asks voters to approve a single change to the city charter: raising the dollar threshold that requires City Council approval and formal competitive bidding on public works contracts, from $1,000 to $250,000. It also allows “competitive ‘best value’” contracting methods, principally design-build. There’s no change to the requirement that contracts go to the lowest responsive bidder. The $1,000 limit has been on the books since 1952, when voters approved the original charter.

Measure C is the remaining product of a comprehensive charter overhaul that a review committee spent almost a year drafting. After council members couldn’t agree on several of its provisions, the council directed the city attorney to draft the procurement provision as a standalone ballot measure. The change is important as the city moves forward with infrastructure projects funded by 2024’s $400 million infrastructure bond, Measure I.

The change would allow the city to use alternative construction methods, chiefly design-build, instead of relying only on the conventional design-bid-build process. Design-build — “master-builder” — was the model for construction projects from antiquity until the Industrial Revolution.

Design-build is a project delivery method for construction where a single entity holds the contract for both design and construction, rather than hiring an architect and a contractor separately under two contracts. With a single point of responsibility, design-build reduces the potential for conflict and finger-pointing and opens opportunities for faster completion.

SPONSORED
Hale_groves_Image.

Levi’s Stadium was built with a design-build contract. This required a special state law (carried by state senator Elaine Alquist) and a new city ordinance (Chapter 17.30).

Measure C supporters, which include Council Members Suds Jain and Karen Hardy, say that raising the threshold would allow design-build on larger projects, potentially speeding up construction and reducing bid inflation.

Opponents haven’t filed a formal argument against the measure, but critics include Mayor Lisa Gillmor and Council Member Kelly Cox, who have said that the measure doesn’t define what counts as a “major” project. As the proposed charter change doesn’t use those words, presumably they were referring to “best value contracting.”

SPONSORED
Pittman&davis_Image.

This isn’t the first time Santa Clara voters have been asked to raise this threshold. In 1994, Measure L proposed letting the city award public works contracts up to $50,000 without published bid notices, with annual increases tied to inflation. Voters rejected it.

For more information, the city clerk’s office has posted Measure C’s impartial analysis and the argument in favor. The measure needs a simple majority to pass.

2 comments

2 thoughts on “Santa Clara Charter Change for Procurement: Measure C”

  1. A “Yes” vote on Measure C is a vote to bring Santa Clara’s government operations into the 21st century.

    Opposing this measure over the $250,000 threshold ignores the reality of modern municipal construction costs. In 1952, completely tearing out and replacing a standard city block of sidewalk cost between $600 and $1,000 total, which is exactly why the charter limit was set there. Today, $250,000 is roughly what a private homeowner spends just to build a single backyard Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU). In public infrastructure, which requires prevailing wages, strict environmental compliance, and traffic control, $250,000 is a small sum that covers minor, routine maintenance like repairing a single block of buckling sidewalk.

    Critics like Mayor Lisa Gillmor and Councilmember Kelly Cox have raised concerns about the ambiguity of what constitutes a “major” project under the new charter language. However, by any realistic engineering standard in Silicon Valley, a $250,000 contract is nowhere near a major project. True major infrastructure, such as a new community center or a critical street expansion, routinely runs between $5 million and $100+ million.

    Neither our city leaders nor our residents should oppose this update. Forcing a full, formal competitive bidding process and a mandatory City Council vote on sub-$250,000 repairs does not protect taxpayers. Instead, it strangles city operations in red tape, triggers lengthy administrative delays, and drives up the final cost of basic repairs. Passing Measure C simply allows staff to efficiently execute minor fixes while keeping the City Council focused on the multi-million dollar contracts that truly deserve strict oversight.

    Reply
  2. Dear Santa Clara voter,

    I’m voting NO on measure C. The procurement method proposed in Measure C will provide less oversight and cost control for our Public Works projects in our City than the current method. A similar measure proposed in 1994, Measure L, was defeated.

    Also the current procurement method, wherein the City Council’s approval is required for public works contracts exceeding $1,000, could easily be raised to $13,000 to adjust for inflation. Measure C raises that threshold for City Council review to an astronomical $250,000, providing no public oversight of costs or type of project. And there is no limit to the number of projects that could be proposed in Measure C at that $250,000 threshold.

    The current procurement process for public works projects, the Design/Bid/Build method, is better for our City than the Design/Build procurement process proposed in Measure C because the design and construction phases are separate in the Design/Bid/Build method. The Design/Bid/Build method is thereby easier to oversee by the City’s civil servants in the Public Works Department, resulting in lower costs and superior quality of construction and building components for public works projects.

    In more detail, the City’s existing procurement process, the Design/Bid/Build method, is better because:

    There are three distinct prime players: City, Architect/Engineer, Builder: Under the Design/Bid/Build method there is no confusion as to responsibilities on the project.

    On the other hand, Design/Build contracts that Measure C would make possible, combines design and construction in one company that results in less incentive to maximize quality of the construction and components of the project on the part of the builder, particularly in the construction of complicated public buildings consisting of many components.

    There are two separate contracts: 1. City-Architect/Engineer & 2. City-Builder: Architects and engineers, the designers, not only produce design drawings and working drawings and specifications needed to construct a project, they also provide assistance to the City during the construction phase, such as the review and approval of documents describing the materials and products to be used in the building that are provided by the building contractor; these documents are called “product submittals.”

    During the construction of the Santa Clara Convention Center, the building contractor employed their own engineers in order to comb through the architect’s specifications in order to substitute as many inferior products for inclusion in the building as they could get away with. Thankfully, the City Engineer had included the duties of submittal review in the contract with the architect who reviewed and disapproved those changes the contractor proposed.

    Under Design/Build contracts that Measure C would make possible, there is less incentive to maximize quality of construction and quality of components in publicly owned buildings, since the architect is in the same company as the builder.

    Contractor selection is based on lowest responsible bid: This process allows for easy comparison between builder’s bids.

    The Design/Bid/Build method includes features that are Essential for the City’s Engineers and City’s Public Works Inspectors to do their job ensuring quality construction.

    1. Well-established and broadly documented roles
    2. Carefully crafted legal and procedural guidelines
    3. Complete specifications that produce clear quality standards that are enforceable: This process allows for easy comparison between builder’s bids; Builders bid on the same construction document package.

    The lowest responsible bid provides a reliable market price for the project: Controls prices paid by the City for public works projects.

    Construction planning opportunity based on completed design and construction documents: Allows construction projects to start at opportune times such as when grant funds are available, when rain is unlikely, and when city personnel are available to administer the contract (selecting contractors and inspecting the construction) on behalf of the City.

    Vote NO on Measure C.

    Thank you,

    Ken Kratz
    Public Works Inspector, City of Santa Clara (retired)
    A.B. Environmental Design, major in Architecture, U.C. Berkeley

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

You May Like